Sign in Subscribe
6 min read

NYT Warning

AI Secret Daily News
Advertise with us
Undatas Unlocks the Power of Data
Click👆 to Watch this YouTube

In the ever-evolving landscape of artificial intelligence and media, a new legal battle has emerged between The New York Times (NYT) and the AI startup Perplexity. The NYT has issued a cease and desist letter to Perplexity, demanding that the company cease using its content without permission for generative AI purposes. This confrontation highlights the growing tension between traditional media outlets and AI firms over the use of copyrighted content.

Background

The New York Times, a venerable institution in the world of journalism, has been at the forefront of legal battles against AI companies that allegedly use its content without authorization. The latest target of its legal ire is Perplexity, an AI startup backed by Jeff Bezos. The NYT's cease and desist letter, dated October 2, 2024, accuses Perplexity of using its content to generate summaries and other outputs, thereby violating copyright law.

Perplexity, on the other hand, contends that it is not scraping data for building foundation models but rather indexing web pages and surfacing factual content as citations to inform responses when users ask questions. The startup has assured publishers that it would stop using "crawling" technology, yet the NYT claims its content still appears in Perplexity's outputs.

The Legal Argument

The crux of the legal dispute lies in the interpretation of copyright law and the concept of fair use. The NYT argues that Perplexity's use of its content is unauthorized and constitutes copyright infringement. The newspaper asserts that its expressive, carefully written, and researched journalism is being used without a license, resulting in unjust enrichment for Perplexity and its business partners.

Perplexity, however, maintains that its actions fall under the doctrine of fair use, which allows limited use of copyrighted material without permission for purposes such as commentary, criticism, or education. The startup argues that no single organization owns the copyright over facts, and its use of web-scraped data is transformative.

Industry Implications

This legal battle is not an isolated incident. The NYT has been involved in similar disputes with other AI companies, including OpenAI, which it sued for using millions of its articles without permission to train its AI chatbot. The outcome of these cases could set important legal precedents for how AI companies handle copyrighted material in the future.

The tension between traditional media outlets and AI firms may also lead to more collaboration between these sectors. Companies like Perplexity have expressed interest in working with publishers to create mutually beneficial agreements that allow for the use of content while compensating creators fairly.

The Broader Context

The rise of AI technologies has transformed how information is accessed and consumed. Newsrooms are increasingly concerned about the potential for AI-generated content to infringe on third-party intellectual property rights. Journalists must be vigilant about the sources of AI-generated content, as seemingly original outputs may be heavily influenced or directly copied from third-party sources without permission.

Moreover, the legal landscape surrounding AI-generated content is still evolving. While Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act provides some protection for web hosts against liability for third-party content, it remains unclear how far these protections extend when journalists use AI tools to generate content.

Why It Matters

The legal battle between The New York Times and Perplexity underscores a critical moment in the intersection of journalism and technology. While the NYT raises valid concerns about copyright infringement, it must also acknowledge that the rise of AI technologies has irrevocably transformed how information is accessed and consumed. The outcome of this dispute could set important precedents for the future of copyright in the AI era.

As the media and AI industries continue to evolve, it is crucial for both parties to find common ground and establish clear guidelines for the use of copyrighted content. Collaboration between traditional media outlets and AI firms could pave the way for innovative solutions that respect intellectual property rights while fostering technological advancement.

Watch YouTube Podcast 👉

References

TOGETHER WITH UNDATAS

Unlock the Power of Data

Undatas converts unstructured data (PDF, DOCX, PPTX, MP3, MP4, WEBSITES) into JSON or Markdown for LLMs. It helps create data pipelines for AI apps and optimizes unstructured data for AI use.

Best Features:

  • 📄 Parse pdf, mp3, mp4 to markdown or json.
  • 🌐 Api mode to parse unstructured data.
  • 🛠️ Build unstructured data parse pipeline for any AI apps.

Managing unstructured data such as tables, images, and text is tough. Converting it to formats like JSON or Markdown slows down efficiency and teamwork.

🎁 Lifetime Access: $97 Only →

This product is provided by Oncely.com. Oncely is the #1 Lifetime Deals Marketplace for AI products. The software landscape has evolved into a Lifetime era — Pay Once, Use Forever, and say goodbye to monthly fees.

QUICK HEATS

  • ChatGPT achieved over 3 billion visits in September 2024, marking a 112% year-over-year increase.
  • An AI-powered bot network on X has been spreading pro-Trump propaganda, supporting Republican candidates ahead of the November elections.
  • Boston Dynamics and Toyota Research Institute (TRI) are collaborating to enhance the AI capabilities of the Atlas humanoid robot.
  • Elon Musk's xAI is actively hiring for 'AI tutors' as part of its expansion efforts.
  • Mistral AI has launched two new language models, Ministral 3B and 8B, designed for efficient AI deployment on edge devices.
  • OpenAI has released a study evaluating fairness in ChatGPT, revealing that name-based biases in responses are minimal, with less than 1% reflecting harmful stereotypes.

AI TOOLS

  • 📝 AlphaNotes generates summaries, notes, and study aids from YouTube videos and websites.
  • 🧥 ClothingAI is a cutting-edge AI fashion designer that helps brands elevate their fashion line.
  • 🪪 Onfido creates trust at onboarding and beyond with an AI-powered digital identity solution.
  • 📲 PhotoRoom generates product and portrait images utilizing a phone.
  • 🗂️ Dex unites LinkedIn, email, and daily tools for managing your connections.
  • 🎧 Tad AI creates original songs with your choice of genres and moods using text prompts. (Featured)
  • 🛒 302.AI offers access to all the top and latest AI. (Featured)
  • 📚 Heardly is the Fast Way to read Best Book. (Featured)
  • 🔀 ChatHub uses multiple AI chatbots at once. (Featured)
  • 🎯 Fork.ai gets app leads with verified emails and contacts. (Featured)

1 Million+ AI enthusiasts are eager to learn about your product.

AI Secret is the world’s #1 AI Newsletter, boasting over 1 million readers from leading companies such as OpenAI, Google, Meta, and Microsoft. We've assisted in promoting Over 500 AI-Related Products. Will yours be the next?

What We Can Offer:

  • Launch an Advertising Campaign
  • Introduce New Product or Features
  • Other Business Cooperation
Reach out today

Email our co-founder Mark directly at mark@aisecret.us if the button fails.

Published by:

Magna Ding